McMahon vs Suarez vs Nothing Hypothetical (which trade would you do)

[Scooterfletcher]

Self explanatory from the title and I wanted to throw this out to the posters as a hypothetical:

1) Suarez - Tobias Myers and Mike Boeve

2) McMahon - Carlos Rodriguez, Luis Lara, Payamps and Peguero (the last two as throw ins for slight salary relief)

3)  Do nothing 

If we are in the final hour before the deadline and you have to pick between these three, which do you choose?

[Playing Catch]

7 hours ago, Scooterfletcher said:

Self explanatory from the title and I wanted to throw this out to the posters as a hypothetical:

1) Suarez - Tobias Myers and Mike Boeve

2) McMahon - Carlos Rodriguez, Luis Lara, Payamps and Peguero (the last two as throw ins for slight salary relief)

3)  Do nothing 

If we are in the final hour before the deadline and you have to pick between these three, which do you choose?

3

[TURBO]

3

McMahon is garbage.  Only way I'd want him is if he is 100% free.  Like the Rockies just said you can have him for $1.  I would give nothing for him, NOTHING.

[markedman5]

 

[MNBrew]

In a vacuum, I'd prefer Suarez over McMahon (obviously McMahon's no longer an option), but not if the cost is crazy high.  What you propose actually wouldn't be that bad to give up, which might also be why AZ says no.

However, I think I'd actually prefer #3.  What we've got has largely been working.

[BrewerFan]

I'm sorry, but we can get Suarez in this scenario for Boeve and Myers and everyone wants to stand put?

 

I have been saying don't give up big time assets for a rental, but... what are these two guys really worth?

Tyler Black is suddenly VERY unpopular. Boeve seems like a less athletic version of Black. Myers...eh, saw something about him hitting 98 in AAA on here. That seemed hard to believe when I saw him throw a couple innings. It's not Logan Henderson. 

That's a trade I'd jump at. 

I think it's absurd to talk about Pratt, Quero(much less the top 2) or Henderson for a 2 month rental, but I'm 100% fine with that deal. Where is Boeve playing in the future? Not 2nd, not 3rd, he's likely a DH... who doesn't have great power. 

[umphrey]

I'm not too attached to Boeve or Myers. Myers would be nice depth to keep next year but he's probably the odd man out of the 5 man even if we lose all our vets.