Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Posted

Don't look now, but the end of Christian Yelich's contract extension is rising over the horizon—still a ways off, but no longer a vague and remote notion. He'll make $26 million each of the next two seasons, with $4 million deferred until next decade. In 2029, the team will decline its side of a $20-million mutual option and pay him a $6.5-million buyout, but $2 million of that, too, will be deferred for a while. He's only still owed almost exactly what Jake Bauers just got from the Red Sox, but since $10 million of that will be paid in installments stretching all the way to 2042, he's really costing them less than Bauers from here on out. For a moment, it looked like this deal might be an albatross for the small-market Brewers. The danger of that passed without coming to anything.

However, Yelich's on-field utility is vanishing about as quickly as the end of the contract is approaching. He last played the outfield with any regularity in 2024, before succumbing to a season-ending back injury that required surgery; he'll almost certainly never be more than an emergency outfielder again. He put up a 152 OPS+ in his half-year in 2024, but that figure fell to 121 in 2025 and crashed all the way to 91 in 2026. He hasn't yet lost measurable bat speed, according to Statcast, but he's cheating a bit to catch up to fastballs, these days. His whiff rate has risen, including on heaters. He struck out 27% of the time in 2026, and he's walked less often than ever over the last two seasons. Before this year, his lowest average sprint speed in a season was 28.1 feet per second. This season, it was 27.5.

There's no shame in Yelich going into significant decline at this juncture. He'll turn 35 early next month. Performance degradation is the default expectation for players at this age, especially in the velocity-mad modern game. The World Series title they just won, alone, is worth as much to the franchise as they'll pay him over the whole lifetime of this contract, and he had a material role in making it happen. He was the team's captain and leader. He secured buy-in to what manager Pat Murphy asks of his young charges. He also had some huge hits this October.

Now, let's ask the tough question: How much extra leash does all of the above buy him? The Brewers make the most ruthless decisions in baseball, on average, but they've always made exceptions for Yelich. How long will that last? He probably should have been out of the lineup more often than he was in 2026, including in the playoffs. History will quickly forget that fact, because he came through when absolutely needed and because the Brewers won, anyway, but it's true. It will be even truer next year. Yelich will be worse; the team will continue promoting young players and need places to play them.

As a designated hitter with a high strikeout rate, a high ground-ball rate and a diminishing walk rate, Yelich doesn't have much of a ceiling or much of a floor. He still puts together tough, intelligent, selfless at-bats, and it's hard to take a leadership role on a team if you don't play often, even if you're a highly paid and beloved veteran. Therefore, Pat Murphy will find ways to get Yelich into the lineup. The question is whether he'll do so four or five times a week, or whether that will become two or three.

If the Brewers want to be a powerhouse again in 2027, they should find a way to make it the latter. Luke Adams won't displace Yelich. Nor will Garrett Mitchell, Luis Lara or Sal Frelick push Yelich to the bench with any frequency; none of them make a great deal of sense as a DH. Whether it's by investing in first base or by adding a bat-first outfielder whose role is more obviously redundant with Yelich's, the organization should use some of its augmented financial flexibility to upgrade its lineup. That will have to mean reducing Yelich's role, which might make for tough conversations. It should happen, though. Yelich can still help the Brewers in 2027, and maybe the same will be true in 2028. If he's asked to take another 500 plate appearances, though, the team will regret it. They should aim to cut that number in half, and see what happens as the campaign unfolds.

Image courtesy of USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

View full article

Recommended Posts

Posted

500 PA of 92 wRC+ for 0.1 WAR doesn't look like a whole lot of bang for $26M at first glance. But what if the player that put those context free numbers together maximized just about every situational split out there?

Low Leverage
228 PA of 71 wRC+
Medium Leverage
223 PA of 100 wRC+
High Leverage
49 PA of 151 wRC+

Bases Empty
256 PA of 80 wRC+
Runners on Base
244 PA of 104 wRC+
Runner in Scoring Position
150 PA of 127 wRC+

Two Outs
160 PA of 63 wRC+
One Out
156 PA of 94 wRC+
Zero Outs
184 PA of 114 wRC+

Trailing in Game
141 PA of .747 OPS (117 sOPS+)
Late and Close
71 PA of .809 OPS (132 sOPS+)
Runner on 3rd, Less Than 2 Outs
33 PA of 1.080 OPS (157 sOPS+)

Put all those ascending situational splits together and Yelich ended up with +1.34 Win Probability Added (59th of 267 players with at least 300 PA) and a 1.64 Clutch Score (9th).

"If he's asked to take another 500 plate appearances, though, the team will regret it."

The Brewers have won the Division by nine, ten, five, and fourteen games the last four seasons. It would likely take massive improvements from the Cubs (or some other NLC team), plus calamitous outcomes for like a half dozen important Brewers players to approach any kind of regrettable outcome.

This year Yelich put up 0.1 WAR, and Woodruff only made nine starts (1.3 rWAR) as the two highest paid Brewers after combining for a cromulent 4.0 WAR in 2025. Sal declined from 3.6 WAR to -0.5 WAR, Peralta (6.1 rWAR in 2025) was traded for negligible return on the 2026 bottom line, Priester (3.6 rWAR) didn't throw a pitch, Quintana (1.8 rWAR) gone in FA, traded Durbin and Collins (2.6 WAR each), lost marginal contributors like Hoskins / Monasterio / Jansen / Mears (2.7 WAR combined) from 2025, this year Woodford / Koenig / Kuhnel / Zerpa combined for -1.9 rWAR, while Jones / Perkins / Rengifo combined for another -1.8 WAR.

Add it all up and that is something like 30 wins in the red between lost performances from 2025 and bad performances in 2026...and the Brewers still won 103 games and the World Series.

  • Like 5
Posted

To justify his roster spot, he needs to be at least a platoon DH. It puts alot of extra tear on the lineup having a positionless player on the bench.

Coming off a WS, and being named Captain, hed have to be Vinny Capra at the plate for them to release him and eat the money. I suspect a very tough decision will have to be made next off-season though.

Posted
41 minutes ago, Rick Daltons Flamethrower said:

Can someone walk me thru why Yelly has never been a first-baseman? No value in the outfield but he is a tall player who could help out there. Why has this never happened?

I don't know but I do remember the talks were happening years ago about it when he was still an everyday LF but because injuries were becoming an issue there was a bunch of worry about added stress and re-injury, etc

Not that I want him opened up to injuries now by any means, but I am a proponent of him learning the position. His value goes up noticeably if he can (at worst) be a break glass option there.

Posted
5 hours ago, Rick Daltons Flamethrower said:

Can someone walk me thru why Yelly has never been a first-baseman? No value in the outfield but he is a tall player who could help out there. Why has this never happened?

The back. Until he started having back trouble (which is 4 or 5 years ago, now), he was fine in the outfield, so no one talked about first base. Once the back started to be a problem, it became almost impossible to move him there. They might yet try it, but I doubt it. I think his (now surgically repaired) spine is a physical limitation that would show up more at first even than when he ventures back to the outfield.

Posted
9 hours ago, Rick Daltons Flamethrower said:

Can someone walk me thru why Yelly has never been a first-baseman? No value in the outfield but he is a tall player who could help out there. Why has this never happened?

I believe his defense is way below average at first base plus his back issues and will be 35 in December.   His 2026, BA was .235 avg slightly under MLB league averages.  He has been having back issues for 8 years now. Vaughn will be the man. 

Posted

Blake Burke didn't do much in Nashville last year .193  https://www.milb.com/player/blake-burke-695501 


  • William Contreras (C): Highlighted as a prominent trade candidate as he enters a walk year, though Milwaukee has expressed interest in keeping him long-term as its everyday catcher.
  • Other Roster & Trade Buzz: Outfielders such as Garrett Mitchell and Sal Frelick face trade or positional questions amid outfield depth, while first baseman Jake Bauers received a $23 million qualifying offer for 2027 after winning NLCS MVP in 2026
  • Trevor Megill (RHP): Frequently mentioned as a potential trade chip this winter, with one year left before free agency after the 2027 season. In 2026, he posted a 2.60 ERA, 69 strikeouts, and a sub-0.90 WHIP across 62 innings as an NL Reliever of the Year finalist.
Posted

Milwaukee will pencil in Yelich for 500 PA at DH until he is physically unable to answer the bell or it becomes so wildly untenable that their hands are tied.

Murphy has demonstrated seemingly limitless patience with Yelich.

Posted
2 hours ago, Frisbee Slider said:

Milwaukee will pencil in Yelich for 500 PA at DH until he is physically unable to answer the bell or it becomes so wildly untenable that their hands are tied.

Murphy has demonstrated seemingly limitless patience with Yelich.

Yes and Vaughn will be our 1st baseman in 2027.  Heard a rumor were looking at Vinnie Pasquantino, KC. Opinion pieces and podcasts have floated Milwaukee as a logical landing spot at first base.

Verified Member
Posted

Give Christian as much time as he wants. 
 

also, Joey had a 2.6 WAR and hit .270 but I hear trade rumors. I hope they're not true.

Posted
18 minutes ago, Brian said:

Yes and Vaughn will be our 1st baseman in 2027.

Starting a post-championship season with veterans in place makes the most sense. Vaughn has the pedigree of a No. 3 overall draft pick who is reaching his prime after overcoming a broken hamate bone. Let the young sluggers behind him earn promotions, but don't sell Vaughn short. 

  • Like 1
Posted
26 minutes ago, izzi said:

also, Joey had a 2.6 WAR and hit .270 but I hear trade rumors. I hope they're not true.

Where?

Posted

For better or worse, it's likely that a 35-year old with a bad back will miss some considerable time.  Leave out 2020, he's averaged 36 missed games a year, with only one year with less than 10 missed games. I think whoever is raking most between Adams, Burke, and Fischer (or Adamczewski even) will get a chance to prove themselves. If they come up and rake in the Bigs, Yeli's back will take longer to heal, and no one questions Yeli's leadership. These things have a way of working themselves out. 

  • Like 1
Posted
2 hours ago, Frisbee Slider said:

Milwaukee will pencil in Yelich for 500 PA at DH until he is physically unable to answer the bell or it becomes so wildly untenable that their hands are tied.

Murphy has demonstrated seemingly limitless patience with Yelich.

I think that is becomes a within reason, type of thing. If he is average overall he will continue to get PAs, if he has a 70 wRC+ versus LHP again you are going to start to see Adams/Vaughn get starts versus LHP and maybe even start to PH in LHRP situation where the RP is within the 3 batter rule. I could see him getting reduced to the strong side of a platoon. 

Posted
10 hours ago, Rick Daltons Flamethrower said:

Can someone walk me thru why Yelly has never been a first-baseman? No value in the outfield but he is a tall player who could help out there. Why has this never happened?

1B requires a lot of stretching forward/diving low and Yelich has a bad back. He actually played 1B in high school. I think he could do it, but I don't think he would be meaningfully better than Vaughn/Burke there and likely worse than Adams. Considering defense is going to be much better and there is more health risk the Brewers have never really done it.

Posted
52 minutes ago, Snoebird said:

Starting a post-championship season with veterans in place makes the most sense. Vaughn has the pedigree of a No. 3 overall draft pick who is reaching his prime after overcoming a broken hamate bone. Let the young sluggers behind him earn promotions, but don't sell Vaughn short. 

It will be interesting to see if the power returns year 2 after hamate injury. If it does look out, but I'm not super confidant it will.

Posted
Quote

He hasn't yet lost measurable bat speed, according to Statcast, but he's cheating a bit to catch up to fastballs, these days. 

Fangraphs had an article (last year maybe) about how whiff rate on Breaking balls is actually the first indicator that a guy isn't able to catch up to heater anymore. Basically they have to cheat to get to FBs and as a result are unable to adjust to spin. Considering Yelich's whiff rate on BBs shot up last couple years, that might be a precursor.

Verified Member
Posted

I am a believer that players must earn their roster spot and playing time.

 

Considering what he's paid Yelich won't earn his roster spot but all things considered it's not in any danger.  His playing time should be.  Platoon him in a very strict fashion.  Match ups only.  Not just DH'ing him mostly vs. RHP but RHP he has a good record with or no record.  A RHP that has owned him, sit him.

That being said we need someone to platoon him with and that just might be with the depth we have on the bench that particular day.  It would be nice to have a Big Papi on the team but we don't necessarily have to have one.

Posted

I don't think Yeli will automatically be worse in 27 than in 26. He clearly lost a step and a tick on bat speed, and needs to make adjustments, which is very hard to do mid season. I wouldn't be suprised if hes back in like a 105 OPS+ range next year, which is prefectly fine for the lineup with the leadership he brings to the young guys. I'd like to see them aim for 400 ABs, rather than 500, just to get more young guys in the lineup to grow.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...