I'd be fine with either one, but would prefer Garza. From the data, Shields appears to be a guy that has to use his fastball to set up his good pitches; his curve & especially changeup look like good pitches. Garza, on the other hand, looks to have a good fastball & solid slider; his change & curve appear to be just pitches he mixes in to keep hitters honest. Shields *does* throw a cut-fastball, which is a pitch that might get better as he continues to throw it (he started throwing it more in '08). In short, Shields looks like an offspeed stuff guy, whereas Garza looks more like a power pitcher. I'd rather have the power guy, I guess. Imo Melvin has to walk a fine line in not overpaying for Garza, but putting a good enough offer out there to keep Tampa from just waiting it out until after Lee signs. Who knows, maybe the Rays are going to wait until after Lee signs no matter what.