Astros offense is actually better. As is their defense. As is their bullpen. And everyone on their team other than Cole did this last year. Which doesn't even cover the chasm between the starting roatations. I usually agree with you but I think you're waaaaay off base on this one. 2018 Yankees: batters 29.4 fWAR (+93.4 offense, -14.7 fielding) (4th in MLB), pitchers 26.6 fWAR (2nd in MLB) 2018 Astros: batters 24.7 fWAR (+64.2 offense, -26.2 fielding) (11th in MLB), pitchers 30.7 fWAR (1st in MLB) And the Yankees improved the most down the stretch by adding Voit, McCutchen, Happ, etc. The Astros are severely overrated, I guess because they are national media darlings and have been in the WS recently? Their pitching staff was so amazing this year because they had 5 top starters. That's sort of irrelevant in the playoffs, where you can get by with 3 starters and a bullpen. That takes away most of what made the 2018 Astros elite. 100 better in run differential. Best bullpen ERA in the league. Better team OPS+ than the Yankees. Better DRS by a fair margin. The fact that Happ, Voit and McCutchen were improvements doesn't actually strengthen your argument either. It's really not close.