Davies and Nottingham were exactly who I thought off too. I figured they would get much more in return. Arguably best 1st baseman in baseball. Carson Kelly is a solid defensive catcher, profiling better defensively than Nottingham. But the values shouldn't be all that much dissimilar. That isn't the problem with the comparison. I mean I think Kelly is a better prospect than Nottingham, but not by a lot. I know I would value Weaver much much more highly than Davies due to ceiling. Weaver obviously had a terrible year last year, but 5 years of a guy with his potential is worth a lot more than Davies. To me at least, and I imagine to scouts as well.