I disagree with the advanced metrics on Yelich's 2018 defense. He is well above average, in my opinion, and has the reputation to go along with that insofar as it matters for voting. Agree. And they're not even close on offense. Yelich is vastly better in every meaningful stat. Edit: Also, just looked at both of their advanced defensive stats. I don't see any evidence that Baez is a plus defender at any position. Decent at both 2B and SS according to DRS and UZR. Are there better metrics than those available? If so, mea culpa. Inside edge paints Yelich as a better defender than Baez, but of course at far less valuable positions. I can't see how an unbiased, informed voter could vote for Baez to be honest.