For what he is being used for right now, he is above average. Look at other bench players in the league and you will see that he is well above average. I cannot stress enough that I don't care how he compares to the average bench player or other players on other teams in his role. We have better options. To say anything different, you just have a ingrained bias that will never change, no matter the evidence proving otherwise. That is false. We should not accept a guy just because he is average if we have a better option. I am biased against having crappy players on ouyr team when we have better options. If we were not playoff bound I would be a little more willing to accept Kotsay to save some service time. And to bring Kotsay up in a Gamel thread is pointless too, seeing that they play different positions. Gamel isn't a left handed bench bat who could play terrible defense in a corner outfield position or back up 1B?