Ask yourself--if McGehee was a 4th round draft pick for the Brewers 7 years ago, worked his way through an unspectacular minor league career, but won a spot with the club out of spring training and continued to have the success that he has had the last two years, would you still think Gamel is a better option with more upside? Yes. McGehee hasn't exactly put up great numbers. He has a career .342/.464/.812 MLB line. He had a .337/.464/.801 line this year. I think Gamel can at least match McGehee's numbers from this year. Probably with a better OBP.