To go along with your assertion, part of the getting less talented each year after 2011 is rooted in the fact that Fielder & Greinke, like Sabathia, passed on the huge money the Brewers offered them for huge-er money from other teams with much deeper pockets. Sure they did but we knew that was going to happen. They sort of ignored that it was going to be an issue. At least Kotsay was previously a CF, whereas Ishikawa was more or less a never-before LF until the injury deal. That Kotsay was exposed was just as much a luck of the draw thing as was Ishikawa's not being exposed.... which I think was your point. Just because a guy was previously a CF doesn't mean he was physically capable of playing there. A guy in CF is much more likely to be exposed than a guy in LF.