Because I bet they will prefer bringing back Counsell, who's a better, more consistent glove up the middle and gets on base. But you're right, backup, they could put Hall in that role and hope he brings some righty power in a very limited role. Of course every thing is subject to change at any time, but at this point the 2010 infield looks like Prince, Weeks, JJ (or Escobar), Gamel, McGehee, and either Hall or Counsell. Counsell is the better compliment to McGehee in this scenario. There are several teams out there with crappy ss, so if they were willing to eat 80% of his contract it's possible they could find a taker.