Sorry, but I'm giving them an F.
We didn't do one single thing that marks an improvement over last year, in fact, I'm pretty sure we may have gotten worse on the whole, while the rest of the division made moves to close the gap on the Central title.
Replacing Adames was going to be tough for a team that refuses to spend, but I really expected a trade that would address our total lack of power in the IF. Didn't happen, instead we got an infielder via trade that we have no idea what he will be. A prospect I guess...
Yes, hopefully, and it's a big maybe, Turang and Ortiz improve and make up some of the ground we lost in Adames. What if they don't? What if they are the exact same players as last year. What if Hoskins is the same player as last year? Can Durbin make up for all that averageness? I just don't see our infield being better than last year, and is more than likely, without replacing Adames' power, going to be worse. Durbin is going to have to shock the world for us to be better in the infield, and that just isn't likely.
Outfield stays the same, however, we will be better there if Chourio plays an entire season the way he played his second half from last year. If Yelich is fixed, that could be an improvement too if he can see the field 130+ games. Mitchell will have to step up and be the guy we have been hoping for, but can he stay healthy? Still have Frelick and Perkins, so not a lot of change all in all. We will 100% need Chourio and Yelich to anchor this offense along with Contreras, or we are in deep do-do, as nothing else is guaranteed.
I suppose Cortes provides us with another stable option, providing he can stay healthy, but we have the guy for one year, that's it. Freddy will be Freddy. We can NOT count on anything from Woodruff until we see what he's all about. He's a HUGE question mark, and could just as easily give us nothing. We already know Hall is hurt, and don't truly know for how long or how serious it might be. Can we count on Ashby? I sure hope so. Civale will eat innings and be a solid #4. We know we won't be seeing Gasser this season. I am counting on Tobias taking another step forward, if not, our rotation could be a mess, especially if we have another injury to contend with.
So to start the season, we are looking at a rotation of this:
1. Freddy
2. Myers
3. Cortes
4. Civale
5. Ashby/Woodruff/Combination of high prospects?
The bullpen I don't worry about. We know it will be a strength as it always seems to be. Does anyone get the most of nothing like we do in the bullpen? Just not a worry imo.
So in the end, how is this line-up any better than last year, and how are we going to hold off the Cubs and the Reds, who have obviously gotten better?
Time will tell, but I'm sticking with an F for my off season grade based on the fact we did next to nothing and our division got better.