I understand the spin you're trying to put on this, however I'll ask how is spending any money on a below replacement level performance a good deal? I understand the point you are trying to make and generally agree with the principle. However, this assumes that in-house or cheap FA replacement level pitchers were available. I can't speak for free agents, however Jack Z's last few drafts didn't exactly stock the cupboard with starting pitching. You can point to Seid, but Garza was signed prior to the 2014 season. It generally takes at least 3-4 years for a college-drafted pitcher to make the majors, and at least 4-5 years for high school pitchers to make the majors. Thus only Seid's first two drafts would have had the time to be ready to step in prior to the 2014 season (only his first draft could have possibly expected a HS pitcher to be ready). For all the criticism that Seid got, every draft of his produced a legitimate starting pitching prospect. Despite the botched first two rounds of 2009, he came away with Fiers and Cravy (and Burgos). In 2010 the Covey pick was a MLB failure, not a Brewers failure, but they still came away with Nelson and Thornburg (and as a HS pick, Covey wouldn't have been ready by 2014). In 2011 they came away with Jungmann and Lopez (and everyone knew Lopez was at least five years away). Fiers and Thornburg were up in 2+ years, but it took Nelson and Jungmann four years to get ready. Jack Z's last three drafts yielded Odorizzi, Scarpetta, and Hand as anything relating to starting pitching prospects. Yes, Odorizzi was traded, but there should have been more than him coming from three drafts. That's why the franchise got to where they had to dip into the FA starting pitching pool. Replacement level wasn't available in-house; thus Garza's win value last year is likely higher than the WAR numbers suggest because alternates would probably have been below replacement level. (If they would have went with Thornburg, he lasted only two months in 2014 before his elbow injury; FA's aren't available in June. Then they certainly would have had to use below replacement-level.)