I am really trying to figure out why the Brewers would not be a favorite. They would still have Braun, Fielder, and Weeks, surrounded by Hart, Lucroy, Morgan and others. Sure SS is still week but 3B should be improved with Green or Casey having a decent year. The starting rotation is still stacked with Peralta there to step in if needed. The bullpen will probably lose some pieces but not insurmountable ones. This team is one the best teams in baseball right now without their all-star second baseman. Not sure why they all the sudden wouldnt be a playoff team. What do you mean by "everything else being equal."