I don't see how. Before tonight McLouth's SLG was 8 points higher than Braun's, so I'm sure now Braun's is maybe just a bit higher, making it a wash. McLouth's OBP is about 70 points higher, which, to me, makes him a better player at this point than Braun. I'd personally go with a starting OF of Burrell, Ludwick and McLouth, and reserves of Dunn, Bay, and Braun.