He's trailing Eric Chavez, Mark Ellis and Orlando Hudson in career WAR and is 45th among active players. Maybe BR overstates the value of defense, but those numbers are striking. Among active 1B/DH, he's behind Pujols, Thome, Helton, Berkman, Giambi, Teixeira, Miguel Cabrera & Ortiz. His career WAR so far is 26.2, putting him 522nd among offensive players. There are some Hall of Famers with low career WARs, but they are also the guys on everybody's list considered as least qualified (Rick Ferrell 26.3; Freddie Lindstrom 26.8; George L. Kelly 23.4; Ray Schalk 25.0; Lloyd Waner 22.0, etc). They were also inducted at a time when politics and favors were more important than stats. I can't see that kind of thing happening in today's time. There are other guys from this current era who are or aren't borderline Hall of Famers with much more value: John Olerud 53.7 Will Clark 53.2 Robin Ventura 52.3 Jeff Kent 51.9 Bernie Williams 45.9 In his very best year, 2010, Konerko was a 4.3 WAR player. He's 36 now, so if you want to project him for another 12-14 points, that puts him around 40 WAR for his career. . . In other words, "You can put it on the boooooooard. . ." No.