Theres is a ton more to it than you let on. Why don't you have to deal with the same budget the Brewers do? The Brewers spent $4.3 million on there top 10 picks in 2004, 1 being Gollardo, while Weaver signed for $4 million himself. Sowers, and Homer Baily, also signed for over slot. Sowers was absolutly destroyed in the majors this year (6.97 ERA, just 19 Ks in 62 innings), and is now a struggling AAA pitcher. He doesn't project well, because he can't miss a bat. Diamond is injured just like Rogers, and didnt show much before that. He hasn't developed an offspeed pitch, which is why his ceiling was as a reliever before the injury. He had kind of plateaued at AA. I have no problem with critizing the pick, but offer 1 viable solution, and preferably not 1 that completely ignores budgett restraints. 2004 has turned out so far to be an awful draft, with tons of 1st round busts such as Chris Lambert, Chris Nelson, Matt Bush, David Purcey, Richie Robnet, Blake Dewitt, and Greg Golson. At least Rogers flashed dominance right before he was injured. If we were going to use hindsite to redo the 2004 draft, theres little doubt that we'd have to use our 1st rounder on Yo Gollardo. Nice work Brewers