"I want guys who will take walks, that is hitting like a professional to me" Ender does that mean you don't consider Braun, Hardy, and Hart to have been professional this year because their walk totals were low? I think Melvin is figuring that Braun will naturally become more selective as Fielder did this year and you will see both of them drawing a lot of walks as pitchers pitch around them. But behind them they will need guys who will more reliably get that RBI single instead of the Jenkins/Hall strikeout trying for that 3 run HR. Hart emerged late as a guy like that and they could use one more, preferably from the left side. Walks are just part of being a professional hitter. The two guys I mentioned, walk at about an average rate, but in the case of Ibanez, he drives in runs at a rate that is more than just coincidence, but is indicative of the ability to hit situationally. I'd much prefer Ibanez over Stewart because he's LH, has more power, and drives in more runs. But they have to give up more to get him, so Stewart is a fallback type. I'm sure Melvin thought he was getting that professional hitter in Estrada. Certainly the lack of walks from Estrada hurt his value, but just as disconcerting were his lack of RBI's and clutch hits. Melvin figured he could live without the walks from Estrada if he got the run production. He didn't get that.