First of all, i think it should be obvious that Beane is a fine GM With that said, i do think a GM should get some flack if quite a few high draft picks produce little or nothing in the bigs. To just say, well the draft is a crapshoot, that absolves the GM of blame for failure or strips away them deserving credit if a player/players do well. The backbone of those good teams under Beane were Zito/Mulder/Hudson. Beane got credit in bringing in those three top notch pitchers, but if the draft is just a crapshoot, he then shouldn't have deserved any credit for the great drafting. It can't be that he deserved great credit for all the fine drafting the A's did for a number of those years and now that the A's drafting hasn't been good as of late, just say oh well it's not his fault since the draft is only a crapshoot. That line of thinking also means guys like Gallardo/Hart/Hardy etc should be taken off Jack Z's resume because it had to be mostly luck because the draft is mainly a crapshoot. For me, i'd just say Beane and his staff of scouts have done a poor job of drafting lately compared to years in the past.