Fangraphs has Suppan as below replacement level for the past 2 seasons, and that's before Monday's debacle. They surprisingly have him being worth almost $11 million in the first year of his contract, so at least he earned his money for 1 year. $11 million or so of value in exchange for 4 years and $42 million is not what you want to see though, and he's at work rapidly deducting value from that $11 million he earned in 2007. In fact, Fangraphs has Suppan and Looper as the 2 worst (qualified, which is .3 innings pitched per team game) pitchers in baseball this season. Signing guys who you hope to be average at best to full value contracts does not appear to be smart. Suppan will be paid $14.5 million next season ($12.5 million in salary and a $2 million buyout of his 2011 option). At least Looper's deal is up after this year and he only requires a $750,000 buyout for next year. Hall is on the hook for $8.9 million next year (including 2011 buyout) and Riske is owed $5 million (including 2011 buyout). That is a lot of totally wasted cash, but even the best GM's will end up wasting some money. $30 million in wasted money out of an $80 million payroll is a higher proportion than you would like to see though. Hopefully the team plans on bumping up the payroll a little next year to try to compensate a little for these mistakes. At least all the bad contracts are over after 2010 (actually, all of the team's contracts except Braun's are over after 2010).