Kind of hard to describe... the guy, Matt Berninger, sings in sort of a monotone voice and the songs themselves are really restrained. I love them, after reading the article I'm not sure you would (though I love Pinkerton, too). It's kind of sad, slow stuff. I've seen them compared to Nick Cave, Leonard Cohen, and Tom Waits, but the only one that I think sticks is comparing them to Tindersticks. They do have the whole "bleary, 2 A.M." feel of Waits I guess. There are hooks and melodies, though.? Their album "Alligator" is sort of their poppier one, though they're definitely not inaccessible at all, but the albums require repeated listens for the most part. The most recent one "Boxer" is one of my favorite albums of the year to this point (maybe my favorite).? Here's a couple videos (both of tracks from "Boxer"): "Fake Empire" on Letterman "Start a War" (acoustic)