Sam makes a good point about how the Rockies scored more runs this past year, so it's not like they're all about pitching and defense. Yes, but it's the playoffs, so everything has to be boiled down to those two things. Look at the White Sox of '05 as another example. I do agree that in the playoffs, though, the late inning reliever takes on greater importance than they do in the regular season. Bullpens are a huge, huge part of playoff success. That being said, I'd still rather be the Indians or Red Sox, because I think they have better offenses, and they can both pitch fairly well. I think having great defense, on the other hand, is more beneficial in the regular season, over a long period of time. Obviously, it helps to have a Troy Tulowitzki in the middle of the diamond any time of the season, but over the course of five games defense can't "save" enough runs to make up for a guy that would have a terrible bat and great glove.