I thought I would resurrect the Sheets debate as it may become more critical in the ensuing months. It has become obvious to me that we just don't have the starting pitching to compete for the division this year. Much of it was losing Yo, but we are filled with question marks beyond. A 2009 rotation of Yo, Soup, Parra, Villy and pick among the host off AAAA guys here or in Nashville won't do it. We need another legitimate 1-2 starter. Maybe Parra will become that guy down the line, but asking him to become Sheets is asking a lot. Drafting 6 college pitchers this year won't do it either. Whether it's Ben or someone else, we need a starter. Here are the options as I see it - 1) Re-sign Ben - It's expensive and the injury history is a risk. For every success, the risk of a Zito type deal could cripple the Brewers, but when Ben is on...he's the ace we need. 2) Trade Ben before the deadline. I know they'll worry about those August/September ticket sales, but this could be an opportunity to restock the minor league pitching depth. Either way, we'll need another arm for 2009. 3) Sign a big free agent. Look what it cost for Suppan...a #3 starter at best. This is not cheap. 4) Trade an untradable player. This one is tough. I'm not talking guys with no value - Bush, Hall, Turnbow or anyone else people are sick of. Do we part with a star? Weeks, Hardy, Hart or Prince? I think anyone but Braun is in play. This is tough too because their replacements at Huntsville are more likely 2010 replacements (I know some of you are more optimistic on this than I am). I'm starting to think we take a chance and sign him, if we can get at least a modest hometown discount. Banking on Sheets, Yo, Soup, Parra & Villy for '09 and betting that Sheets can stay healthy. The question is can they get him for 3-4 years and if he gets hurt will it completely handcuff us. Emotion aside...what should DM do?