$12m a year for a 4.5-5 ERA pitcher is a disaster when you can get someone like Woodruff, Miley, Guerra, and Suter for about a tenth of that. Lynn at Miller Park would be bad and Cobb at Miller Park would be even worse. People hated Garza and Lohse and that is basically what you will be getting with Cobb and Lynn it is just that most see oooh new shiny thing and think that it will be different this time. Both Lynn and Cobb are bad pitchers for Miller Park and both would put up around a 4.5-5 ERA and be paid about $12m a season. Not a good idea and yes that is a disaster.