Unlikely as Hoskins isn't all that great after you take the HR's away. He is not a good hitter as he is only a career .242 / .353 / .492 hitter. His slugging in his last full year was only .462 and his OBP also dipped to a career low of .332. Would you rather pay $8mm for .242 / .356 / .432 production or $18mm for .242 / .353/ .460 production? The first is Santana and the second is Hoskins. Hoskins just won't outproduce Santana by $10mm. It would be dumb to sign Hoskins at $16mm+ for multiple seasons when you can get nearly the same production and better defense from Santana for far less. This is not being cheap either the production just doesn't justify the price difference. If it were Ohtani at $18mm versus Santana at $8mm then yes you take Ohtani at $18mm over Santana but not Hoskins. You are basically paying double for what Santana costs compared to Hoskins when you are not getting double the production or even better production.
I think Hoskins will do something closer to what Bell did last year which was .247 / .325 / .419. You really want to pay Hoskins $16mm+ a season to get that kind of production? Or how about Conforto last year who hit .239 / .334 / .384 is that what you want to pay $16mm+ a season for? Black is projected for a .240 / .342 / .401 season which if he hits that would be equal to what Hoskins is likely to put up in 2024. Santana is also projected for about the same. Hoskins is not someone I want the Brewers to spend $16mm+ a season for and neither is Chapman. These players you keep bringing up are just not worth $16mm+ a season. Let some other idiot sign them for that and only get production out of them that should cost $8mm a season or less.
Chapman and Hoskins are just not players teams should be investing $16mm+ a season in especially more than one season. I would rather sign JD Martinez to a one or two year deal at $14-16mm per season than go anywhere north of $8mm a season for Hoskins or Chapman. There is a reason why neither of these players have signed a contract so far. No team is willing to meet their asking price and rightfully so.