Let's arbitrate this... Miller $4,500,000/year one year of arbitration AGE AVE OBP SLG FLD(349 games) 28.9 .240 .314 .411 .964 Sogard $2,4000,000/year free agent AGE AVE OBP SLG FLD(124 games) 32.2 .238 .309 .315 .973 When I put down the numbers, I basically say neither is a long term or short term solution. Miller has more power and Sogard is a little more nimble in the field. Other than that they are pretty much the same (not very appetizing). So if I had to pick with the entire history of the two, I would pick Miller because of the added power (better chance of winning a game late with a pinch hit double or home run). Neither should be in the game late protecting a one run lead. That is my opinion, Miller by a couple of hairs.