I am not calling JJ a bad player. I do think his 2007 first half was extaordinary, propelling him to the all star game. I personally would categorize him as an abover average shortstop, maybe even top ten, despite his first 2+ months this year. I personally would not label him as an "all-star shortstop" because to me that implies that the guy is a perennial participant in the game. He has not been to this point and I don't think he will be a guy you'll see there consistently. I hope he gets back there. But I'd put "above average shortstop" JJ Hardy as opposed to "All Star shortstop" JJ Hardy when talking about the guy. Just my take, not saying I'm right here... Also, Escobar has not yet peaked, so to think that he'll automatically start hitting below .300 or whatever "cooling down" means, well, I am just not so sure. He's definitely not playing above his potential based on his numbers he has this year. And his numbers are very good. But his ceiling is even higher than his current years' numbers suggest.