You just said JJ has better stats in the last 3 years and you picked 2009. Let's see.....225 BA, .298 OBP and a OPS of .653 which includes a .365 slugging percentage. Then throw in the blazing speed of JJ with 5 career steals. Vs Escobar's stats of which isn't better? Hmm....2008 season when he batted .328, an OBP of .363 and had an OPS of .797. Well, there goes that theory. And I noticed how you changed the wording to try to fit your argument. I was just looking at the OPS that endaround posted earlier, which Hardy's was significantly higher. I'm not really big on the consistent vs streaky hitter thing (IMO its just all a huge coincidence), but do we know that Escobar is any better? He's seemed fairly streaky to me, and his career month-to-month splits jump around just as much, if not more. Impossible to be sure of this, but the point is that 1) the transition from AAA to the majors is not always seamless, and 2) a player's major league numbers are almost always going to be worse than in AAA. If Hardy's injury makes those points moot, then look at Rickie Weeks instead. Or just about every other player in the history of baseball. You might want to do some refiguring because this season alone is better than what those 3 average.