I was an avid Strat O Matic player back in my college and grad school days in the 70’s.
The thing there is that, unlike real baseball, if you know what you’re doing, the precise mathematical probabilities are staring you in the face. But many times the dice and cards wouldn’t produce the desired result. At least there you knew you made the correct move and could just blame bad luck. Plus, there were no fans telling you how stupid you are.