I know that I wasn’t as disappointed in either of those seasons, though 2012 might have been close. In 2009, Sabbathia was gone and Sheets was down with injuries, taking away the one-two punch that propelled them into playoff position and gave them just enough cushion when they collapsed in September, in part because of Sheets’ injuries. Throw in the manager change and it was a significantly different team. In 2012, Fielder was gone and the Braun suspension threat put a cloud over the offseason. The way Wolf and Marcum finished the 2011 season made the starting rotation questionable too. The 2019 Brewers seemed to have a good chance to have improved offense and equal or better pitching, with more options than they had as starters to begin 2018. I didn’t expect 95 wins again, but thought 90 was a real possibility and better wasn’t out of the question. There were none of those questions of “Can they replace the production they got from...” any of the major contributors in 2018. It was pretty apparent by the All Star break that both the hitting and the pitching were falling far short of expectations, much less hopes. And nothing has changed since then.