But according to CC's manager manual, Hader can only pitch in games the brewers lead by a few runs or are tied and since June 1st that hasn't happened often. Barnes OTH pitches when the team is behind or ahead by a lot so he's had more opportunity to play (the behind part mostly as being ahead by a lot is pretty much impossible with this team).. Since the end of May this team is a 500 ballclub that had built up a 16 win lead. That puts them on pace for 89 wins without looking at strength of schedule, etc. So they are still very much in the chase for a wild card, but a team that has struggled to put any sustained winning streak for 2.5 months and is looking more and more like a 500 team is very unlikely to march into the post-season on a tear. Could happen... Likely won't happen... To add to this, Hader’s stats since June 1 say something about the Brewers’ decline since then. On May 30, Hader and Knebel finished off 3-2 win over the Cardinals to complete a series victory. At that time the Brewers were 36-21 with a 4.5 game lead over the Cubs and at least a 2 game edge over everyone else in the NL. Since then they have gone 30-32, which is worse than every playoff contender except the Nats. Through May, Hader had appeared in 19 games (all Brewer victories) pitching 33 innings and allowing only 4 earned runs (ERA 1.09) with an amazing 66 strikeouts and opposing hitter OPS of .347. Since then, he has appeared in 19 more games, but only covered 23.1 innings. His ERA is 2.31 with an opponent’s OPS of .553. He has struck out 35 hitters. He has also picked up 2 blown saves and one loss and the Brewers are 12-7 in the games that he has pitched. So, he has still been very good, but significantly less spectacular and less prolific than the first 2 months. In April and May the Brewers picked up a lot of wins by getting through the first 5 or 6 innings with a small lead and using some combination of Hader, Jeffress, Albers, Jennings, Barnes, Williams, and Knebel (when he returned from the DL) to finish out the game. They did that with amazing efficiency, often with relievers covering multiple innings in a game. Things are a lot different now. We all know what has happened to Albers (who was better and more valuable than people remember the first two months) and with injuries and regression for Williams, Soria, and Barnes, plus Knebel’s problems, the bullpen is now a shadow of what it was in May. The ability of the bullpen to cover short starts has been greatly reduced. As for Hader, it seems that he is often being saved for situations that aren’t arising that often, as evidenced by the significant drop in his innings pitched. He also hasn’t been as dominant, making it more difficult for him to cover multiple innings. The Brewers are still in the thick of the race, but to keep pace with the other contenders they’re going to have to find a different formula for winning than they used in April and May. Since getting more innings from the starters doesn’t seem likely, it’s probably going to have to come from a significant improvement from the offense. While there have been some signs of improvement there, they haven’t been big enough or frequent enough to get the team off the .500 train.