What's really impressive is that De Jesus has put together a full career of 4 partial seasons (545 plate appearances) where his stat line is about on par with Villar's terrible 2017 season. Well Villar is going to continue to be Villar-level bad. We're in August now. and IF Dejesus is also Villar-level bad then you're no worse off than continuing to play Villar. At least try something different. This is all assuming (which I think we can) that Sogards fall from grace will continue and Perez will never learn how to take a pitch Because we know what to expect from Sogard and De Jesus and likely Kinsler given all of their ages. We know it won't be much better. There is a lot of data to back that up. Yes, I will agree with you that Villar is probably broken for this season and we likely also know that his numbers will be bad. However, if you said "I have a crystal ball and one of those 4 players ended up as August and September offensive MVP for the Brewers" I would wager 60% of my money on Villar, maybe 30% on Kinsler, 9% on Sogard, and 1% on De Jesus. Why? Because Jonathan Villar was a highly regarded prospect at one point and has actually produced results before and therefore there is actually a reasonable probability that he can do it again. Kinsler is an OK option because he once was good but is getting old. Sogard and Ivan De Jesus are 100% known commodities of AAA journeyman. the only reason people want to try them is because it's something and less frustrating to the human eye to watch when they're struggling in comparison to Villar. When you incorporate history, defense, baseball IQ, and bad luck his year (low BABIP+high hard contact rate) Kinsler is better than Villar and it's not that close