I dont agree with every decision Murphy makes, but the guy gets waaay more criticism than praise on here. Defending him doesn’t mean I think he’s perfect, but if a pitcher blows up, it’s often Murphy who gets criticism (used a guy too much, left him in a batter too long, etc). But when they shut down an opponent with Mears, Uribe, Megill, no one will credit Murphy. .588 winning percentage.