If the Brewers miss the playoffs this season I will be very disappointed. I think I miscalculated a little bit on how good this rotation could be this year, but some things didn't play out. I don't know the thought process of Stearns and co, but I felt that Davies and Anderson were going to be stabilizing figures in the rotation this season and were the two most dependable starters for this team in 2018. The two have been anything but. Davies has been injured and ineffective when pitching. Anderson has been inconsistent and had his fair share of blow ups with very few stretches of quality production. I also thought Nelson might come back this season even though i didn't have much faith in him being a big contributor in the amount of innings or quality of production. If he had made it back this season it would have given me a little more hope for him to pitch quality inning in 2019, but now that's a pretty big question mark. I think Stearns has some questions to answer when it comes to the 2019 staff if he wants to take a step forward. Woodruff, Peralta, and Burnes should all be in the rotation next year, but that's dangerous for a team who wants to contend. If those three are in the rotation, that only leaves 2 spots for Davies, Anderson, Guerra, Chacin, and Nelson. I'm not married to Guerra. He's been useful the year, but he's probably the guy they're least invested in due to age and contract situation. Davies is a guy they could upgrade over. He's probably not much of an option out of the pen. He probably doesn't have much trade value given his injury plagued 2018, but he's too good to non-tender. He's probably the most interesting name to follow this off season. Anderson is someone they might be able to trade given his relatively cheap control and average numbers this season. Given what he'd likely return though, I'd just assume hang onto him and hope he bounces back in 2019. Chain could probably work out of the bullpen effectively given his highly effective slider however given how good he has been this season he will have to get bumped from that starting role due to poor performance. Nelson is a big wild card. Given the severity of that shoulder injury it's entirely possible he is never an effective pitcher again. We know you need ~10 SP to get through a season so depth is important. The interesting question is how the Brewers move forward with the 3 young starters. If they're not going to pitch them out of the rotation will they move them in a trade for a more established starter? The free agent market does have some interesting names including Morton, Kuechel, Happ, Corbin, Eovaldi, etc. Kuechel and Corbin are probably out of the Brewers price range. Drew Pomeranz seems like a David Sterns type move. Buy low on a guy coming off an injured/ineffective season who has a history of success. I wouldn't be opposed to a Wade Miley reunion as well.