We went into this season with no 3B and no true 1B, two offensive positions. (I do understand that Hiura sucking as bad as he has wasn't fully expected, but the writing was on the wall based on last season) We absolutely needed one more bat at either position. What do we do instead, sign JBJ, another outfielder with no bat. Shaw has worked out, but what a question mark that signing was. You can make all the excuses you want for anyone you want but the plan going in was questionable. I am not fully blaming any one person, but I don't think the plan that we started the season with offensively was a good one. Hiura or Yelich goes down and we are screwed. Just so happens that what has happened with both of them could quite possibly ruin the season. What was our back-up plan if Hiura (a guy who has never played 1B) didn't work out? Vogelbach our full time 1B? Our 1B plan was horrible, and we are now paying the price. Shaw can play 1B, ok great, but then that leaves us with no 3B. It is what it is.