I speak pretty glowingly of the Brewers org I love and cover throughout the Minor League season. I do this on a consistent basis. I love the team and always will.
However, in this case boy do I find it absolutely hard to believe they didn't follow up on this injury back in September. This is your Ace closer. One of the premier late inning arms in the entire League. He should have been handled proactively and in constant communication once the season ended (I'm not saying they didn't do this but I certainly question how they managed it or what paths they took). This appears to be a failure of assessment and process. The only hope we can have here moving forward is they learned from this and will seek out specialists sooner. I mean, for crying out loud they had an entire off-season to do this type of thing. I commend your POV on this @Matthew Trueblood. And let me also be clear I'm not disdainful in any way but man is this smelling of oversights or siloed mistakes. I am a bit in disbelief. It would be one thing if this miraculously just popped up. It seems quite abundantly clear it did not. And, it also seems clear, when it did pop up the 'specialists' in house didn't know what they were actually looking at or how to look at it. I struggle to understand how a major sports team doesn't have the top specialists in the country on speed dial. This is a back issue flaring up? Who is the premier back specialist or specialists. Let's exhaust these avenues.
Let me put it this way:
If you were somehow a 'small market' Formula One team...and you had a dedicated garage of Ace mechanics. A dedicated team of specialists. And an Ace driver who drove an absolutely top of the line Ace car...and all of the sudden late in the season during a crucial race to chase crucial points, your driver says he notices something different in the sound and feel of the car. BUT, your mechanics run through their diagnostics and their wind tunnels of assessment and vision. AND, nobody can really find anything. BUT, even after the season ends, your Ace driver continues to take this same Ace of a car around laps in practice courses and he insists he continues to feel irregularity and something is consistently just, well, off. Sure, there might be some good days but it still manages to pop up routinely despite the good days. Tell me, as the team owner or someone within the decision-making team, you don't pipe up and ask for an independent assessment from outside the organization? You don't trust your Ace and follow that course to receive multiple opinions from outside the organizational group think? In another manner of speaking, bringing it back to the 'real world', when something goes wrong in our car or in our house do we not seek multiple opinions? Receive multiple quotes or ideas and then marry the consistent discovery?
Devin Williams may not be angry at or with the Brewers, but I sure as heck hope the Brewers learn from this and improve their process and avail themselves to seeking highly specialized outside counsel earlier in circumstances that require it.