It is hard for me to reconcile some of the dislike for Jake Peavy, his ERA, his contract, splits, etc etc. Didnt the Brewers offer CC Sabathia a 5 year 100 million dollar deal this offseason? Now I know perhaps some of you who object to Peavy also objected to Sabathia but many well respected posters on this site would not have minded that deal, so here me out. If Sabathia had accepted the Brewers would be on the hook for: Sabathia: 2009-$20million, 2010-$20million, 2011-$20million, 2012-$20million, 2013-$20million = $100 million Peavy: 2009-$8million, 2010-$15million, 2011-$16million, 2012, $17million, 2013-$22million = $78 million Age: Sabathia born July 21, 1980 Peavy born May 31, 1981 Peavy is a year YOUNGER Innings pitched: Sabathia = 1,730 Peavy = 1,334 Cy Young Awards: Sabathia - 1 Peavy - 1 Injury worries: Sabathia: tons of innings and bad body or could be Bartolo Colon by the time deal is done Peavy: supposed sloppy mechanics or could be Ben Sheets by the time the deal is done Road ERAs: Sabathia: 3.65 Peavy: 3.84 So as far as contract + inuury concerns go, if you liked Sabathia, you SHOULD like Peavy as well. The big, big difference is that we have to trade players to get Peavy and we wouldnt have to get Sabathia. Ahh, BUT we would NOT have gotten two comp picks for Sabathia if we had resigned him so..... Send the Padres: Parra OR Jeffress, not both Evan Anundsen Angel Salome Tim Dillard Replace two of them this draft.