They’re not arbitrary value websites. It would be solid core but we still can and should do better. Orioles might be reluctant to part with their prospects, but it’s the price you have to pay.
Freddy is healthy right now and controllable for 3 more years after coming off a second half where he was arguably the best pitcher in baseball. Devin is arguably the best (top 3 at minimum) closer in the game and is controllable for 2 more years.
That’s a Juan Soto combination of value. Trading guys for less than their value, especially when they’re controllable like Peralta and Williams are, is right out of the A’s playbook.