It strikes me that Dana has gone in the space of a month from getting overblown praise to receiving overdone criticism. I tend to agree with you and I think it has a lot to do with his "less than super prospect" status. His numbers at AA were terrific and I think that excited people a great deal. He had a fair amount of success when he first came up and that excited people even more, so he was celebrated. When he struggled, people were disappointed, moreso because he struggled badly at the end of the season. Whether that was because he was fatigued physically or mentally due to the number of innings he pitched, or because he was out of shape, or a change in his routine I don't know and I don't think anyone else does either.