but I'd be surprised if he has more than 162 games at third. 156, second in games played to SS. He never played 3B in the minors. And Mr. Thecrew07, it ain't flawed logic. IF, you were doing what he said Taking one AB from a game from a player on a hot streak (aided greatly by facing many LHP in the last 10 days) and claiming it to definitive proof of as why any player is better than another is flawed logic at best. then it is. 1 AB is always meaningless, no matter how great or awful, as even Randy Johnson has produced an amazing AB in the last 36 hours. If people seem to have a short fuse in these discussions, a historical perspective will explain it. Branyan debates tend to turn into painful lobbing of anecdotal evidence, small samples, and appeals to intangibles and front office decisions. I struggle with the concept of "complete hitter" as it seems to be used as a magic label by people who promulgate the superiority of one player over another when there's an absence of real proof. It's like saying a guy's grit and hustle make him better than the numbers suggest. These data (stats) come from actual in-game performances, so it's hard to say the intangibles make a difference in areas that can be quantified and display contrary data. Studies have been done with look at the relative run production of different AB outcomes, but still it will be argued that this is hooey.