I get what you're saying. At some point though, some players are just so bad they deserve to not start anymore. I would say Betancourt is definitely at that point. Roenicke should be benching him as an example of what happens to players who don't improve, and go with a Counsell/Wilson platoon until Melvin gives him a real shortstop. Maybe Yuni is a great guy who his teammates like (no evidence of that, just speculating), but his approach and defense are horrid. He should not be starting, regardless of how mediocre the alternatives are.