For the record (since I started the Hoffman thread), I was just starting it to have a fun discussion, coinciding with the hoopla of his 600th save. I lean in the camp that says, "No, they probably shouldn't retire Hoffman's number." Let San Diego do it. However, he is a likely Hall of Famer, and that is the criteria that the Brewers have used when retiring numbers. (The only exception being Don Sutton, who wasn't a Brewer for very long and was more identified as a Dodger). Ben Sheets was a very good pitcher; but other than an outstanding 2004 and very good, injury shortened 2008, never really rose to the level of being an elite starting pitcher in the majors. Barring a miracle comeback, he will not be a Hall of Famer. Thus, he doesn't meet the criteria the Brewers have established. I really don't think there would be any justification for retiring his number. If you retire his, you should also retire Jenkins'. Maybe even Vaughn and Burnitz as well.