Well, you may be right Briggs. Anyway, I remember reading that the White Sox may have been willing to throw in a bat to "sweeten" the deal a bit. I don't know if that was ever confirmed or not, but I don't remember it being framed as "Hudson for Fielder, straight up" during the trade deadline. If Melvin can't get a pitcher back at least as good as Hudson for Fielder this winter (or at the least another player of similar value, pitcher or not), it's going to be pretty disappointing.