Again, you're comparing one season or half season rentals to a position player with two years of team control left. The payoff for trading Fielder at this point should be much higher...otherwise Melvin will just hold onto him, pay him his relatively affordable salary next season, and possibly trade him before the deadline to some team in need of a quality power hitter (if the Brewers are out of contention next July). They can again STILL look at trading him next winter. Granted, they won't get as much for him by then, but they can still get one or two good players. Or just hold onto him, let him leave after 2011 when he inevitably doesn't re-sign, and take the compensation picks. There is barely any downside for the Brewers here, which is why they are going to demand a lot in any realistic trade scenario. To be blunt, I think that reasoning is why they will more than likely hold onto him this winter...you can't get enough from any team, realistically, that makes it worth trading him at this point. The production he will give the Brewers next season probably outweighs what they will get from any collection of trade candidates. He's that good.