I do think the idea that Melvin should have had the clairvoyance to trade Hardy and/or Hart is a bit misguided. You can argue that he should have done more to acquire better pitching, and if that meant dealing either of those to, then so be it. But to say he should have known both would have such down years is just arm chair quarterbacking after the fact. According to the statheads on here, Hardy was worth way more than his current salary...so why trade him after such a great year? People would have been screaming if they tried to make Escobar the starting shortstop and he struggled early. No one knew Counsell would have such a tremendous rebound year, either. As far as trading Hart, that would have just opened up another gap in the outfield. Hart basically only had a couple rough months last year, but overall was a very good player. And yes, the repeated calls for trading for a young starting pitcher are kind of tiresome. Like fondy said, teams just don't trade those kinds of pitchers much anymore. Maybe because they are sick of giving out Jeff Suppan type contracts.