You're right. Almost every free agent signing in baseball can be considered a risk. However, I just think that, assuming this is another injury for Sheets (where he misses more than one start), the risks outweigh the potential reward. This is a pitcher who hasn't pitched over 200 innings since 2004. I just don't see how you can justify throwing huge long term money at someone like that. If this was any other player, we probably wouldn't be having this discussion, but because it's Ben Sheets and he's "our guy", it seems like a lot of people are willing to look past the many drawbacks of him as a player, and look past his recent and verifiable track record. You have to sign guys based on recent track record, and what they can reasonably be expected to do in the future. A team like the Brewers can hand out huge contracts based on "stuff" and "potential." It's a recipe for really handcuffing the team's finances later on. I don't see how you can look at him and say he's due to reel off a slew of Cy Young contender seasons. He has "the stuff", but not the health track record for that. He's not getting younger, either. Look, don't get me wrong, I'm all for the Brewers resigning Sheets if it is for a reasonable contract...it just doesn't seem like that is likely based on recent FA pitcher signings in MLB. Seriously, I thought in the fifth inning last night, "Wow, you really have to appreciate Ben Sheets when he's on, and what he can do on the mound." And then ironically, he was pulled following that inning. It's like a bad comedy, really.