You throw out a trade idea that would make any GM a complete idiot to hold on to Kneble. Its about what it cost to get Chapman as a rental for the Cubs. Problem is Robles wouldnt fit Milwaukee, so I would turn it down to the effects of finding a 3rd team to trade Robles to, and get a player who'd fit Milws needs. Everyone has a price, when they will be traded for Golden Tickets but, where this team is already at, that is what it must take for me to trade Kneble this early in his career. As theres a huge need for a player of his potential. I'm not trying to make fun of you, but in your first sentence you say 'that would make any GM an idiot (to not trade Knebel for Robles), then in the very next sentence you say 'I would turn it down.' I agree with your first instinct. It would be utter insanity to turn that down. If you get offered a top 5 prospect for Corey Knebel you take it regardless of the position. Value is value. It's not like Robles wouldn't be tradeable later if you wanted to go down that road.