Fair question. I guess if it were September. Yes. Or playoff baseball, ABSOLUTELY. But in April, on back to back days, I just think doing that every time the situation arises will burn out your closer. (unless you plan on your team being bad and not having a whole lot of save situations). Mabe this is bad logic. I don't know. I'm just thinking long-term. I have NO problem with the premise of bringing him in being the "right" move. I just feel like it runs the risk of burning him out. The "burnout" argument holds merit, it's really the only argument I can understand for why you shouldn't do it. Mathematically, if we were assuming any pitcher can throw an unlimited amount throughout the year, it would be in a team's best interest to use the better relievers first to ensure that the tie is not broken and therefore the offense continues to get chances to win. But if you're saying that doing it throughout the course of the year may put too much of a strain on your closer and make him ineffective later in the year, I can buy that.