Lucroy is not even close to one of your 5 best hitters, why hit him 2nd? He has a .307 OBP over 2 seasons. He's had one month (April, 2011) where he had 50 AB's and OBP'd over .326. He's not a table setter. Last year, he might've been a good choice to move up in the order when McGehee, Gomez, and Betancourt were all hitting in front of him. He has a .307 OBP hitting in front of the pitcher. He's a contact hitter that will excell in front of Braun. That's why. Actually, he has a .338 OBP hitting 8th. Its under .300 in every other spot in the lineup. He hits lefties well enough to be moved up, but hasn't hit righties in his career.