A little against the spirit of the thread, but I think the easiest and best solution is to get Sheets back in a four year deal. I don't care how much, just as long as its only 4 years or less. If we are planning on seriously competing next season, I think we are an offseason too early to trade away our bats and expect the young AA guys to produce effectively in the bigs. The only real way to throw out a playoff calibur rotation would be to trade from the minors or retain Sheets. If we trade from the minors, we really risk killing our post-Fielder window. I don't think Sheets salary would hinder our future team's ability to compete nearly as much, even if he fails to meet expectations. We still have the pre-arby players regardless, plus Braun and maybe another guy inked long term, as an offensive core. Extending Sheets instead of trading from the minors also means we can still trade guys like Hardy, Weeks, and Fielder the following offseason and have replacements in place. In 2010 we can target another top young arm, as well as possibly seeing Jeffress debut that season. My action steps: 2009 - Resign Sheets to a 4 year / $100 million contract with a 5th year, $30 million option and a $5 million buyout; effectively a 4 year / $105 million contract 2B Weeks SS Hardy LF Braun 1B Fielder RF Hart CF Cameron 3B Hall C Kendall SP Sheets SP Gallardo SP Parra SP Suppan SP Bush Prospect Debuts: Gamel, Escobar 2010 - Trade Fielder for a younger, quality starting pitcher C ???/Salome/Rivera 1B ???/Gamel 2B Weeks/Hardy 3B Gamel/Hardy/Hall SS Escobar LF Braun/Gamel CF Braun/Hart/Brantley/Cain/??? RF Hart/Braun/Gamel SP Sheets SP Gallardo SP Fielder Trade SP Parra SP Suppan Prospect Debuts: Salome, Brantley, Cain, Jeffress, Braddock A lot of internal flexibility in 2010 and beyond even without financial flexibility due to a hefty Sheet commitment. Pitching-wise, we could have three sub-4.00 ERA starters in 2009 and four sub-4.00 ERA starters in 2010 with Parra being the wildcard. It'd be expected of Sheets, Gallardo, and the pitcher acquired in the Fielder trade.