So, because runners underestimated Kendall's arm strength he should not get credit for the runners he threw out? I'm not sure I'm understading the logic. I clearly said "to his credit he did well". How has Kendall faced any weaker runners than Molina has and how would Molina do any better in a Brewer uniform? Managers are going to send more runners against weaker throwing catchers. Up until 2008, Kendall had struggled throwing out runners, so more runners are going to be sent when Kendall is catching than Molina -- as more runners run, they are most likely to be slower runners. In 2007, Kendall gave up 111 SBs and only threw out 20 dudes. Only 50 guys ran on Molina in 2007. I am certain going into 2008, a number of managers saw Kendall as an opportunity to get some cheap bases. In 2008 Kendall only gave up 51 SBs and threw out 41. Only 52 guys ran on Molina. Going into 2008, Kendall needed to prove that he could throw out runners, and he did. Managers knew that running on Molina (with the exception of elite baserunners) was a bad gamble. That said, if the same 92 guys ran on Molina that did on Kendall, I am certain that Molina would have converted more of them into outs than Kendall did. The same thing goes for OFers... not a lot of coaches are going to run on a guy like Francoeur -- but they are probably going to be willing to test out Hart's arm out quite a bit more, and until Hart starts gunning out runners, he will get more attempts than Francoeur, and probably rack up more assists -- it hardly means though that Hart has the better arm.